Leader Talk

FDI after 30 years in Vietnam: The worst failure lesson drawn from Formosa

By Thu Phuong August 24, 2017 | 12:00 PM GMT+7

Formosa, a giant steel project in Ha Tinh central province causing the worst water pollution ever in Vietnam, is a failure of the country in attracting foreign investors, forcing it to draw lessons to change for more successes in the future.

A corner of Formosa Ha Tinh (Source: fhs.com.vn)

It is undeniable that the foreign investment with the Foreign Investment Law promulgated in 1987 has significantly contributed to Vietnam’s socio-economic development, promoting the international economic integration.

Besides the achievements, the foreign investment sector still shows some drawbacks. Especially, the Formosa disaster caused by Taiwanese Formosa Plastics Group in four coastal provinces of Vietnam namely Ha Tinh, Quang Binh, Quang Tri, Thua Thien – Hue being internationally highlighted in 2016.

Analyzing the 30 years of attracting FDI with real lessons is necessary for Vietnam to define a better direction for the upcoming time.

Lesson drawn from Formosa

According to Ph.D. Phan Huu Thang, former Director-General of the Foreign Investment Agency (under the MPI), following the environmental disaster in Thi Vai river caused by Vedan (Vietnam) Enterprise Corp., Ltd., organic fertiliser and feed additives manufacturer, Formosa has been the most terrible water disaster in Vietnam. “Formosa can be seen as Vietnam’s worst failure in attracting foreign investment and managing FDI due to the loose management of the state administration and oversight authorities,” said PhD Phan Huu Thang.

Chairman of the Viet Nam Association of Foreign Investment Enterprises Nguyen Mai also stated that Vietnam should consider attracting FDI in the areas that are environmentally friendly and have the positive impact on socio-economy. Especially, sustainable development must be the top priority. 
Ph.D. Phan Huu Thang, former Director General of the Foreign Investment Agency (under the MPI)

Pointing out the lessons drawn from Formosa case, Ph.D. Phan Huu Thang believes that Vietnam’s policies to attract FDI are still inadequate. Specifically, there are limited collaborations between domestic and foreign investors while 100 percent foreign-owned enterprises (FOEs) are currently dominant. As a result, Vietnam would find it hard acquiring modern technology and detecting wrongdoing and monitoring activities of companies efficiently.

The State management agencies also need to overhaul their management as well as their uncompleted policies, investing more time in the currently implemented projects and carefully consider the new ones to choose the most qualified FDI projects.

After 30 years of applying the FDI attracting policies, Vietnam needs to undertake changes regarding the modes of investment and corporation.

Financing Southeast Asia’s energy transition

Financing Southeast Asia’s energy transition

Leader Talk -  3 month

The energy transition is bringing forth new challenges, particularly in refining financial systems.

Few countries are better placed than Vietnam for consistent robust growth

Few countries are better placed than Vietnam for consistent robust growth

Leader Talk -  3 month

Alex Hambly talks about investment opportunities in Vietnam following his appointment as chief investment officer (CIO) of VinaCapital.

The secret to employee retention

The secret to employee retention

Leader Talk -  3 month

As Furama-Ariyana Danang international tourism complex has just won the “Best Companies to Work for in Asia” HR Asia Awards 2024, TheLEADER talked with its HR and training director Nguyen Thi Minh Tam to find out more.

Young leader of Timor-Leste: Vietnam offers valuable lessons for growth

Young leader of Timor-Leste: Vietnam offers valuable lessons for growth

Leader Talk -  4 month

The young leader of East Timor emphasizes that Vietnam has a lot of development experience that East Timorese businesses can learn and cooperate with.

May the draft amendment of VAT law demotivate Vietnam’s export growth?

May the draft amendment of VAT law demotivate Vietnam’s export growth?

Leader Talk -  4 month

A prominent issue for many Vietnamese businesses concerns the proposed narrowing of the 0 per cent VAT rate for export services.

Vietnam in a new FDI shift

Vietnam in a new FDI shift

Leader Talk -  7 month

HSBC discusses Vietnam's role in supply chain relocation and outlined essential strategies for the country to enhance its appeal for attracting and retaining FDI.